Tournament of Books, Round Two: Moxie vs Prince in Disguise

Prince in Disguise by Stephanie Kate Strohm

25844635All of her life, 16 year old Dylan Leigh has lived in the shadow of her reality TV star and beauty queen sister, Dusty, never quite measuring up to other’s expectations of her.  So when Dylan is dragged to Scotland as part of Dusty’s wedding to Ronan, a Scottish laird, there’s nothing she wants to do more than disappear. Unfortunately, the always-on and always-close cameras documenting the weeks leading up to the wedding and the hawkish producer Pamela won’t let that happen as she keeps finding ways to cast Dylan in an unflattering light. But when Dylan meets the charmingly awkward groomsmen Jaime, she starts to feel as if she’s really being seen for the first time. She just wishes it wasn’t being filmed for reality TV.

In this high school version of The Bachelor meets Princess Diaries, with a touch of Bridget Jones’ Diary, readers are drawn into a story that features witty banter, charming characters, and some genuinely laugh-out-loud funny moments. The highly romanticized fairy tale setting of a Christmas-time, winter wonderland Scotland, replete with horse drawn carriages and snowy kisses, is no less than what you would expect of a Hyperion (Disney) book. Strohm even manages to throw the reader off by including twists that aren’t twists alongside twists that are (got that?), and even more impressively, finds ways to allow secondary characters to develop beyond their one-dimensional first impressions. This is a mostly clean read that is sure to provide feel good vibes to whomever picks it up.

Moxie by Jennifer Mathieu

moxieAfter years of keeping her head down at school, the usually “dutiful” high school junior Vivian Carter can’t stay silent anymore about the rampant sexism occurring all around her: dress code violations are enforced on the girls while boys are able to wear lewd and tasteless t-shirts, teachers turn a blind eye to boys participating in the so-called game bump’n’grab, and funding for girls’ sports and education take a backseat to funding for the football team. Vivian doesn’t feel brave enough to speak out publicly – she doesn’t want to disappoint her family – but, drawing inspiration from her mom’s 90s feminist punk history, she decides to create an anonymous zine to give voice to her anger and frustration. What starts out as a small call to arms eventually turns into a movement, and Vivian discovers she had more moxie than she ever imagined.

This book touches on important topics and does so in a manner that is believable, inclusive, and praiseworthy. Besides including an unofficial soundtrack throughout the story and back matter that will lead readers to more resources on feminism, Mathieu peppers the entire book with moments that any aspiring feminist – either girl or boy – can appreciate. Not letting Seth get away with his subdued but ingrained misogyny was a true show of character for Vivian, no pun intended. Mathieu also includes LGBTQ characters and characters of color, but does so in ways that aren’t preachy or over the top. While it’s easy to wish she went more into the discrimination these characters face – she does touch upon it – in addition to the harassment they have to deal with, the reader knows this story isn’t about those issues per se, and so the characters are merely there, having the same awful experiences and fighting the same fight as everyone else. That is, in its own way, a refreshing change of pace.

And the winner is…

Moxie by Jennifer Mathieu

At first glance, these books seem vastly different in the stories they will tell when in fact, they have quite a bit in common. Though one looks saccharine and bright, and the other dark and edgy, both tell the stories of fatherless, physically commanding (tall), romantically stifled Southern girls who do their best to remain unseen until an outside event forces them to own their own worth. Both are given a shot at first kisses and first boyfriends while they try to navigate the choppy waters of learning to defy expectations (both their own and others’) in order to lead the life that’s meant for them.

Both stories lived up to the expected conventions of their respective genres (romance and realistic fiction) but in this hashtag-happy era of #WeNeedDiverseBooks, #MeToo, and #TimesUp, Moxie’s unapologetic feminism and inclusiveness of racial and sexual diversity puts it on top in the battle between tall Southern belles coming out of their shell.

Alea Perez has enthusiastically led the Youth Services department at the Westmont Public Library, located in the Chicago suburbs, since 2015. For 9 years, she has aimed to help children, teens, and their caregivers discover the joy and wonder of libraries in both IL and AZ and recently ended her term as Chair of YALSA’s Great Graphic Novels for Teens.


Back to Round Two, Bracket Seven

Onto Round Three, Bracket One


Tournament of Books, Round One: Prince in Disguise vs Want

When I received the books for my tournament bracket, I was already in the middle of Prince in Disguise. So, Prince automatically gained a few points due to it being a book I was already reading without adding another title to my ever-growing list. Want, on the other hand, is a diverse sci-fi dystopian novel, and I’m a sucker for diverse sci-fi so they both started out with points on a pretty level playing field.


want-9781481489225_hrIn future dystopian Taiwan, there are yous who live in luxury and meis who live in poverty. Pollution and illness is rampant, especially for meis without the resources to buy suits to purify the air. Zhou and his group of mei friends have a plan to take down the you infrastructure and bring environmental reform. Their plan means Zhou must infiltrate you society and live as a you to gain information.

If that paragraph was confusing, with meis and yous, nearly the first quarter of the book felt similar. I thought the use of “you” as a people group throughout the book would drive me crazy, and it did at first, but the world-building is superb, the action great and really my enjoyment of the book overtook my annoyance relatively quickly. Want reads similar to a younger, less complex Red Rising.


25844635The premise to Prince in Disguise is just so crazy, it’s believable. Dylan has lived her whole life in her beauty queen sister Dusty’s shadow. Dusty ended up on a reality TV Bachelor-like show called Prince in Disguise (where the “Bachelor” is a prince, except Ronan isn’t a prince – he’s a lord). Dusty and Ronan are engaged and planning a wedding in Scotland, which is the focus of a special season of Prince in Disguise. The book opens with Dusty asking/informing Dylan that she will be a part of the wedding edition of the reality TV show and get to spend a few weeks in Scotland. Dylan is less than pleased (to say the least) she would rather not be on reality TV at all. When Dylan arrives in Scotland she is constantly being put into less than flattering situations, but at least there is Jamie, a cute, funny groomsman of Ronan’s.

This book is full of funny and awkward scenarios, weird twists, and family drama. I definitely expected a few of the “twists” but a couple of them surprised me as well. Though, the surprise of the twists was less “I didn’t see that coming!” and more “Of course, that’s how it would go down on reality TV, how did I NOT see this!!” It reads like a combination of The Bachelor and The Royal We, in all the best ways. Reading this book will give you all the delightful guilty pleasure of an evening spent watching The Bachelor or trolling the internet for Harry and Megan rumors (not that I have such experience 😉 ).

And the winner is…


Prince in Disguise by Stephanie Kate Strohm

Honestly, these two books were neck and neck for nearly the whole time. I wasn’t sure how I was going to decide, and it came down to the ending. Both of these books follow pretty popular storylines and have lots of tropes. In the case of Prince the fun had with the predictable twists was the exact point of this sort of novel. In the end, Prince was able to fully embody those tropes, while adding something to the conversation – love at 16 might not be end game while still having a happy and satisfying ending. On the other hand, Want’s ending felt like a back loaded information dump. The ending of Want had twists and a lot of information to set up for a potential sequel, but it felt like too much at the end and not enough throughout. So yay mushy-crazy-royal-reality-TV-romance!

Bio: Cyndi Hamann is the Teen Librarian at Crystal Lake Public Library. She enjoys baking and binge watching while playing Tetris. Muggle.

Back to Round One, Bracket Fifteen

Onto Round Two, Bracket One